How do we distinguish observation from interpretation?
Many disagreements begin when we report what we think happened as if it were what we saw. This challenge trains you to separate the recorded fact from the explanation you add to it.
Why it matters
Science, journalism and everyday decisions all depend on knowing which part of a claim is evidence and which part is inference. Keeping them apart lets others check your evidence and propose different explanations.
Steps
- Choose a simple scene you can watch for ten minutes, such as a street corner, a plant or a classroom.
- Write two columns: in the first record only what can be seen, heard, counted or measured; in the second write possible explanations.
- For each explanation, note which observation supports it and which observation would contradict it.
- Ask a colleague to read the first column only and propose their own explanations, then compare.
Expected output
A one-page observation sheet with two separate columns, at least three competing explanations and a short note on what further observation would help decide between them.
Assessment criteria
- The observation column contains no judgements or assumed motives.
- Each explanation is linked to specific observations.
- The sheet states what remains uncertain.
Safety and ethics
Observe public spaces respectfully, do not record identifiable people without consent and do not publish photos of others without permission.
